Policy Matters
Blog Home All Blogs
Administered by the Blog Committee, Policy Matters posts are written by members on a variety of topics. From think pieces to how-to's, editorials to news round-ups, there is something for every policy administrator. Interested in contributing a post? Let us know by emailing admin@acupa.org.

 

Search all posts for:   

 

Top tags: policy  policy development  Policy Administration  Jessica Teets  policy process  collaboration  Deborah Bartlett  pandemic  accessibility  COVID-19  Jennifer Gallagher  Gina Kennedy  writing  ACUPA  data  equity  IT  Productivity  remote work  How-to  Lisa Biagas  news  resources  Sara Gigeroff  students  AI  change  compliance  culture  free speech 

Policies as More than Rules

Posted By Megan Jones, Metropolitan State University of Denver, Wednesday, January 22, 2020

"Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter."
–Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.


**This blog represents my personal views rather than the official position of MSU Denver or ACUPA.**

Developing community standards rather than rules

Often when I tell people that I work on policy, they respond with, "So you make the rules?" While this question often amuses me, I’ve come to view policies as much more than rules.

In “Decolonizing Hispanic-Serving Institutions: A Framework for Organizing” (Garcia, 2018), Dr. Garcia argues that HSIs “must recognize their history of colonialism before moving toward an organizational model grounded in decolonization” (p. 132). One way to do so, Garcia claims, is to create community standards within an organization rather than rules.

Garcia describes community standards as “dynamic and fluid” (p. 139). “In a decolonized organization,” Garcia writes, “members develop rules, regulations, and policies as needed to protect…and to progress as a community.”

Bringing Multiple Voices to the Conversation

Garcia argues that community standards are “complimentary to the decentralized governance structure in that standards can and should be created by multiple people within the organization, including students, faculty, and staff” (p. 140).

Creating welcoming and respectful spaces, such as policy advisory councils, open forums, and cross-functional workgroups, that acknowledge and adapt to the diverse backgrounds of students, faculty, and staff leads to better synergy between constituent groups, senior leaders, and organizational areas. Rather than being viewed as rules that unnecessarily restrict behavior, policies are viewed as community standards that uphold the shared values of the organization.

References

Garcia, G.A. (2018). Journal of Hispanic Higher Education, 17(2), 132-147.

Tags:  advisory council  colonialism  community standards  decolonization  governance  Hispanic-Serving Institution  HSI  open forum  organizational theory  rules 

PermalinkComments (0)
 

Inclusive Policy Development

Posted By Megan Jones, Metropolitan State University of Denver, Monday, July 29, 2019

Metropolitan State University's Policy Advisory Council

The views expressed in this article are my personal views and do not represent the official position of MSU Denver or ACUPA.

Metropolitan State University of Denver recently restructured its Policy Advisory Council to be more inclusive of various perspectives throughout the university. The council, a group that I helped to establish in 2016 and continue to facilitate, provides recommendations to MSU Denver leadership on university-wide policies and policy impacts prior to enactment or revision. In 2018, as part of MSU Denver’s inclusive-leadership movement, MSU Denver President Janine Davidson, Ph.D., opened the council membership to any interested student or employee at the university. A year later, the council has about 65 total members, comprised of students, faculty, and staff, with 20 to 25 of those members attending any given monthly meeting.

While having a large number of individuals on the council can make meeting and coming to consensus more difficult, the benefit of having diverse perspectives, particularly when it comes to implementation, training and communication, outweighs the challenge of including many voices in the process.

Conflict Management, Not Resolution

Involving multiple perspectives in the policy process will eventually lead to conflict. “Conflict is growth waiting to happen,” said MSU Denver Human Services Professor Tony Ledesma, during a peace-studies learning community. Instead of viewing this conflict as a problem to be resolved, I’ve learned to view the friction in the policy process as a force for positive change. Often, when there’s friction, there’s passion. The most outspoken faculty, staff, and students sometimes get reputations for being difficult or obstructive. Rather than viewing dissident community members as a roadblock, policy managers can channel negative energy and harness “difficult” individuals’ passion by including the most outspoken opponents in policy planning and development.

Focus on Students

When President Davidson began her tenure at MSU Denver, she said her priorities were, “Students, students, students.” In higher education, prioritizing students seems obvious. However, immediately following Dr. Davidson’s declaration, MSU Denver employees began to ask, “What about me?” It’s all too easy for administrators and faculty (who are pressured from many angles and also enjoy intellectual interests of their own) to forget that educating students and preparing them to succeed throughout their education and career is the main focus of their work. This case is especially true when the council is talking about policies on employee leave or financial conflicts of interest, which may seem unrelated to students. Yet, the wellbeing and satisfaction of employees often has a trickle-down effect on the satisfaction, retention and graduation of students. When conflicts arise during the policy process, reminding everyone of the organization’s emphasis on “students, students, students,” helps to unite disparate viewpoints by focusing individuals on a common goal.

Looking to the Future

While managing such a large council occasionally leaves me in introvert overload, the success of the inclusive process is worth the effort. In the past year, for example, the council conducted a comprehensive review of the Board of Trustees’ policy manual, and it plans to tackle the staff employment handbook next.

Tags:  advisory council  conflict management  development  inclusive  policy  process 

PermalinkComments (1)